Back to Calculators

Tech Pay Plan Comparison

Compare flat rate, hourly, and hybrid pay structures side by side.

Technician Inputs

Pay Rates

Metric Flat Rate Hourly Hybrid
Labor Revenue $0 $0 $0
Tech Pay $0 $0 $0
Labor GP $ $0 $0 $0
Labor GP % 0% 0% 0%
Effective Cost / Billed Hr $0 $0 $0

Understanding Pay Structures

There's no universally "best" pay plan. The right choice depends on your shop's culture, workflow, and team. Here's what to consider:

Flat Rate

  • Pros: Rewards speed and efficiency. Top producers earn more.
  • Cons: Can incentivize rushing work. Tech pay drops when car count is low.
  • Best for: High-volume shops with consistent car count.

Hourly

  • Pros: Predictable cost. Less pressure on techs. Encourages thoroughness.
  • Cons: No incentive for productivity. Higher cost per billed hour if efficiency is low.
  • Best for: Shops focused on quality or with newer techs in training.

Hybrid

  • Pros: Guaranteed base + performance upside. Balances quality and speed.
  • Cons: More complex to administer. Must track production accurately.
  • Best for: Shops wanting to retain talent while incentivizing results.

Benchmarks referenced from leading automotive coaching groups including ATI, Elite Worldwide, Transformers Institute, Shop Fix Academy, 180BIZ, DRIVE, and the Institute for Automotive Business Excellence.

Track labor cost per tech in real time

PULSE calculates effective labor rate, tech productivity, and labor cost per billed hour automatically.

See PULSE in Action →